(Through 2018-19 Season)
| Coach | Seasons | W-L | Winning Percentage |
| R.C. Super | 3 (1906-09) | 4-5-1 | .450 |
| Prof. K.P. Harrington | 2 (1909-11) | 10-4 | .714 |
| Prof. L.A. Howland | 2 (1911-13) | 7-1-4 | .750 |
| Prof. W.G. Cady | 4 (1913-17) | 15-13-3 | .532 |
| R.P. Swift | 3 (1918-21) | 15-4-1 | .775 |
| R.T. Steele | 3 (1921-22, 1925-27) | 19-14 | .576 |
| Hugh McCurdy | 20 (1922-25, 1927-46) | 95-74-5 | .560 |
| Jim Reid | 2 (1946-48) | 14-10 | .583 |
| John L. Wood | 2 (1948-50) | 7-10 | .412 |
| Stan Plagenhoef | 16 (1950-65, 1966-67) | 74-68 | .521 |
| Don Long | 38 (1965-66, 1967-2004) | 200-250 | .444 |
| Ken Alrutz | 8 (2004-2012) | 74-65-1 | .532 |
| Mike Fried | 7 (2012-pres.) | 75-48 | .609 |